Will Covergirl's Exact eyelights still work if I get a different shade?

I have blue eyes and it works with the Black-Sapphire but if I get regular black, will it still work?Will Covergirl's Exact eyelights still work if I get a different shade?
Kay, your asking a whole new question there...Will Covergirl's Exact eyelights still work if I get a different shade?
If you get regular black its not Exact Eyelights..